I'm not sure how far this discussion will go but I have had an idea for a trilogy of stories for sometime now. I thought it would be interesting to document the process.
To begin, you should know I created a story about Joan of Arc many years ago. I can’t recall now why I did, it may have been a request or just something I wanted to do, but I have always loved Joan’s story, the tale of a teenage girl’s courage and faith beyond all odds. I have not told it in a long time and so I suspect it will go through some additional work. It will be one story in this trilogy.
Before I talk about The Maid of Lorraine, I will share another piece of my usual process. I like to have a title to work with as it helps keep me focused, but for now this trilogy has no title. That may come along as I get more involved in the research. I have decided on three Medieval woman as subjects for this trilogy, Joan of Arc, Eleanor of Aquitaine and Hildegard of Bingen. Hildegard will be my first research project because I don’t know as much about her as I would like and she fascinates me.
Joan of Arc, or Jeanne d’Arc: Joan lived in a man’s world and because of this she lived by the law of man and the law of the church. I looked at four different stories about Joan, and I often refer to children’s stories because they are as bare bones as you can get. It’s a good place to get small details. Each story offered a different look at Joan. I collected information on her childhood and daily life, dates, places, what brought to her a place in her life where she would decide to openly break the law of the church and take the role of a man and so on. As a child I was taught she was burned as a witch but in fact if you read enough about her you learn that the church could not find her guilty of witchcraft but instead used its laws on the conduct of women against her. She was burned as a heretic. But I never found any account that really allowed me to get inside her head and see things from her perspective, perhaps because she was a woman and most writers were men. Using historical accounts and what I know of the lifestyle, I could have “made up” what Joan would think and say. But I felt that would not do her justice so I chose a different point of view (POV).
Steps so far:
1. Chose a story
2. Find as many versions of that story as you can
3. Learn something of the time, place, customs
4. Choose a POV
My POV for Joan’s story was a woman whose husband joined Joan’s campaign, fought beside her, and returned to tell his wife all that had happened. Then she tells the story of her own interaction with the Maid and what her husband had relayed. Now I can give the opinion of the woman I have created and nobody can dispute whether she said or did what I have given her to say and do. Still I must stay within some societal confines of the culture and time period for my story to feel real.
I don’t know exactly what the next post will be but my plan of action is to read about Hildegard of Bingen and see if I can connect her life with Joan’s in some way, not physically but metaphorically or philosophically. I am looking for a “thread” to bind the stories and help me determine where to place each one and how to tell them in the trilogy.
Wednesday, July 28, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

This is the second post to this blog regarding a historical trilogy.
ReplyDeleteI have not gotten as far as I'd like in my reading but I began with Hildegard of Bingen. I discovered connections between her and Joan of Arc. These connections will act as threads that help me develop my story.
Hildegard was given to the church at about age 7 or 8. She was literally walled up in a cell. She saw visions she attributed to God at this early age just as Joan did. Hildegard was given many freedoms usually accorded to men, such as the freedom to be a prolific writer and preacher. Joan also had such freedoms but hers was slightly different. Joan was a figurehead while Hildegard was acting as a leader. Also in commonality was the desire to have them sainted. I have not yet read if Hildegard was actually approved as a saint but I did read that during her lifetime, sainthood was often a choice of the people. This was also about the time that the laws of the church changed to make it necessary for the church to approve sainthood.
My research will continue and I am not yet certain how this thread will come into use but I sense it has some part to play.
Here it is early October and I am no further in this research. I began reading about Hildegard of Bingen. The book I have is a slow read, and I am a slow reader to begin with. Summer is just a very busy time to do research, too many other activities and now I have been asked to write a second book about local history/folklore, not to mention some research on some family history that has peaked my interest. I think I will have to put this trilogy on the back burner again and focus on my book about working with at-risk youth and the new local book.
ReplyDelete